Thursday, February 12, 2009

Affirmative Action

I fully support what i stated today in class. Because I feel that there shouldn't be a need for affirmative action, however, maybe just more financial aid towards the minorities, because minorities have the same exact potential as the whites and Asians(that is if Asians are not considered a minority in this situation). I understand that minorities mainly come from a typically poorer area than rich white people, but that should be factored into their application essays, and that they came from a school containing less-experienced teachers. Despite that, they still have the exact same potential to get at least a 4.0 and do some extra curricular activities. However, there is also the conflict of time, where minorities with less money have to work to help support their families while going to school, or they have to take care of younger siblings, and they don't have any extra time for sports, clubs, community service, or other activities. In that case, colleges consider that into your application. I even went to the college awareness thing last night and the college counselor talked about that, and if you don't have time for extra activities for certain reasons, she said to put that on their application and the colleges fully consider that factor. Furthermore, an example of my point earlier, is my brothers friend who graduated from the magnet program at Cleveland three years ago, and she was Guatemalan, with not that much money. However, she ended up getting over a 4.0 every year and was even the president of few clubs, and this bought her a full-ride scholarship to Harvard. This shows that despite where you come from, and despite what your parents do for a living and how much money they have, you can achieve this same experience and there is no excuse because everyone has the same potential.

5 comments:

  1. for the record greg, you get financial aid (loans and grants) based on your income and how much you are expected to pay for college... financial aid boosts are not necessary because it is already available in generous amounts

    ReplyDelete
  2. ok greg. first of all, it doesn't matter that your friend was a minority. You cannot take a single person of a certain race and set them as a standard for all minorities, especially when we do not know her background. How do we know if she happened to have a great family who pushed her to do everything she possibly could to get into Harvard - help her get scholarships, or even take care of everything, so that all she had to do was go to school and get good grades. Or maybe she was one of those crazy schoolalldayallthetime kind of people, whose parents were REALLY into getting good grades (and she stood right along side them). Or maybe she even had some kind of contact at Harvard, who helped her. A single girl's situation should not stand for EVERY minority persons case.

    (that's what i wanted to add from my answer to your question from today :] )

    ReplyDelete
  3. yeah greg, one sample is not enough to make a case study either, in amandas defense

    i agree with your basic idea (affirmative action is not necessary) but the rest of it i dont agree with

    ReplyDelete
  4. i understand what you are saying amanda but her father was a gardener and i know that they didnt have any hook ups with harvard, and besides harvard, she also got a full-ride scholarship to stanford and yale.

    ok and myles, im am just using financial aid as an example, im am just trying to say that there are other smaller things that colleges do for minorities instead of affirmative action.

    ReplyDelete
  5. regardless, you still cannot use one girl as a case study for all minorities

    and there isn't much colleges can do aside from affirmative action. maybe lower tuition/room&board so that not so much money is loaned out. or perhaps be more lenient on things like grades and SAT scores and pay even more attention to the essays.

    honestly, the only option i see working is the one written out in my blog

    ReplyDelete